Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator

Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator

This article discusses what Adobe Illustrator, Affinity Designer and Sketch are and their pros and cons and features in order to come up to a conclusion to meet the required – Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator.

 Adobe Illustrator

A Guide To Graphic Designing

Initially released in 1988, the software has gone through more than two-dozen generations spanning 26 years. Needless to say, Adobe has had a long time to gather information about what users want and need. The tools and user interface are mature and familiar. Illustrator is the de facto standard by which all vector software is measured.

Affinity Designer

Guide to Affinity Designer

Affinity Designer, by Serif Labs, is the newcomer on the block and is the Editor’s Choice winner on the Apple App Store at the time of this writing. Affinity Designer incorporates some familiar aspects of Illustrator’s user interface while adding its own touches and approach to vector design.

Sketch

Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator

Sketch, by Bohemian Coding, is a two-time Apple Design Award Winner in 2009 and 2012. Sketch already has a lot of traction among icon designers, including Jon Hicks of Hicks Design. The sketch is quickly becoming the tool of choice for many apps and web designers.

Let us have a comparison of the features of Illustrator, Affinity, and Sketch in order to get the conclusion of Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator:

Task / Feature Adobe Illustrator Sketch Affinity Designer
License Model Subscription-only Perpetual (1-time) Perpetual (1-time)
Price $19.99 per month $99.99 $49.99
Custom Grids Yes Yes No
Shape tools Yes Yes Yes (on steroids)
Drawing Excellent Fair Good
Join Points & Segments Yes No Yes
Pathfinder Yes Yes Yes
Snap-to-Point, Snap-to-Grid Yes Yes Yes (on steroids)
Multiple Artboards Yes Yes No (on roadmap)
Pixel  Preview Yes Yes Yes
Pixel Preview (Retina) No No Yes
Export to SVG, PNG, etc. Yes Yes Yes
Batch save Yes Yes (on steroids) No
Pixel-perfection Yes Yes Yes
Miscellaneous:
Object selection Yes Yes Yes
Direct selection Yes Yes Yes
Area selection by marquee Yes Yes Yes
User Interface Dark Native Dark
Intuitive/Familiar Yes No Yes
Customizable (can rearrange) Yes No Yes
Scripts & Actions Yes Yes No
Scriptable Yes (JavaScript) Yes (CocoaScript) No (on roadmap)
Platforms Mac & Windows Mac-only Mac-only

 

Now let us go through the Pros and Cons of the software.

Adobe Illustrator

Pros:

  • Maturity – which has allowed Adobe to work out a lot of kinks and collect a lot of user data
  • More extensive feature list
  • Longevity – Illustrator will still be around in 10 years
  • Ubiquity – Nearly anyone can work with .ai files
  • Interoperability with Photo and Desktop publishing tools
Cons:

  • Subscription license not very popular
  • Greater Total Cost of ownership
  • 100 art board limit is arbitrary
  • Can’t customize grid on each artboard

Sketch

Pros:

  • Only $100
  • Predefined Icon art board templates
  • Simultaneous export to multiple locations, multiple sizes, and multiple formats
Cons:

  • Mac OS only
  • Drawing tools feel clunky and imprecise
  • Tools are somewhat lacking (join points, direct selection, etc)
  • Conspicuous lack of some UI norms such as Command+space zoom

Affinity Designer

Pros:

  • Only $50
  • Pretty nice selection of tools. Not as extensive as Ai but has most of what you expect
  • UI is familiar-ish since it mimics Ai in many ways
  • 1,000,000% zoom, yes One Million percent zoom!
  • Strong incentive to disrupt the vector software space
Cons:

  • Mac OS only
  • Drawing takes some getting used to
  • Lack of artboards is very limiting
  • Lack of scripting ability and/or actions
  • Lack of batch export to different formats
  • No custom grids

 

Summary:Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator

Each product has its strengths and weaknesses. Affinity Designer is a strong contender, especially considering it is first generation software. Adobe Illustrator has always been the first choice of Professional designers, while Affinity or Sketch can be a pick of the newbie.

Hope you find this article, Affinity Designer and Sketch versus Adobe Illustrator of help. Happy designing!

 

Leave a Comment